Woyano Home - My Friends - My Topics - Inbox - Join - Login
Love and Sanity in a Chaotic World
Modern Psychology and Practical Advice (you don't have to lay on the couch for)

Subscribe to
My Woyano network and Friends list!

Enter your email:

Would you breastfeed your child to the age of 5?

Rate this:
By georgie (Contact - View My Woyano)
Published Sun 13 May 2007, 3080 Views, 34 Comments

Attachment Parenting is considered by some to be a healthy, nurturing way to raise children. This method has sparked some debate in recent years because, although it is supported by some medical practitioners and rooted in theories of infant development, its practices do seem unorthodox compared with common and conventional parenting styles.


Attachment Parenting is a philosophy based in the practice of nurturing parenting methods that create strong emotional bonds, also known as secure attachment, between the infant and parent(s) This style of parenting encourages responsiveness to the infant or child's emotional needs, and develops trust that their emotional needs will be met. As a result, this strong attachment helps the child develop secure, empathic, peaceful and enduring relationships.

The Eight Ideals of Attachment Parenting.
  • Prepare for Pregnancy, Birth, and Parenting
  • Feed with Love and Respect (includes breastfeeding until age 2 and beyond)
  • Respond with Sensitivity (includes responding each time baby is crying and distressed)
  • Use Nurturing Touch (includes "wearing" baby in soft carrier rather than using a pram)
  • Engage in Nighttime Parenting (includes co-sleeping, sleeping with baby in parent's bed)
  • Provide Consistent and Loving Care (includes avoiding frequent or prolonged separations)
  • Practice Positive Discipline (includes teaching child to make positive choices based on stage of development)
  • Seek Balance in Personal and Family Life (includes making time for the couple and encouraging fathers parenting)
To read more about the principles of Attachment Parenting, visit www.attachmentparenting.org


This Item
Feature
Flag as Adult
Flag as Inappropriate
Category: Knowledge, Snippets, General
Tags: attachment, parenting, children, babies, breastfeeding
Contributor
georgie
Add to friends
Contact
View My Woyano
Share it
Link to this item:
Bookmark this item: RSS Feed

People who liked this item

    34 Comments

  1.  
    JV ~ 35 months ago
    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
    Would you breastfeed your child to the age of 5? Yuk.
    [ reply ]
    1.  
      penumbra2000 ~ 33 months ago
      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
      Why 'yuk'? It's a normal part of life in lots of cultures around the world, much like women with underarm and leghair, men in skirts, and so forth.
      [ reply ]
    2.  
      snak ~ 35 months ago
      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
      I wouldn't have thought it possible except in exceptional circumstances. Human Breast Milk is better than formula for babies because, well, it's 'Human'. It's *designed* to be good for babies, whereas formula is *designed* for cows.
      Mother's milk is the finishing touch to rounding off a new baby. It contains everything the baby needs in terms of nourishment and, perhaps more importantly, protection from illness.

      After a while, mothers milk changes. When the baby is sufficiently nourished, the taste changes to one the baby does not like. This is natural and is necessary.
      Forcing a child to feed from the breast after the taste of the milk becomes unpalatable, would be nothing short of cruelty.
      [ reply ]
      1.  
        penumbra2000 ~ 33 months ago
        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
        ...is that true? I've never heard that about the changing flavour thing.

        In any case, I agree that forcing a child to breastfeed when they don't want to any more would be cruel and probably psychologically damaging, unless it was so early that they risk malnutrition.
        [ reply ]
      2.  
        georgie ~ 35 months ago
        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
        snak, I would have thought the infant's teeth coming in would be reason enough to end breastfeeding! Though I have heard that in some poor third world countries, for example, breastfeeding continues much longer than in Western countries, as it is more traditional and there is less food to go around.

        If mothers continue to have children, then they might continue to breastfeed without the milk changing. Perhaps a three year old on one side and the newborn on the other!
        [ reply ]
        1.  
          penumbra2000 ~ 33 months ago
          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
          I'm pretty sure that the North American custom of a short breastfeeding cycle is very unusual among human cultures. I don't have a citation handy for that, though. Definitely women continue breastfeeding after their children get teeth; all of my mother friends breastfed beyond the teething line.
          [ reply ]
        2.  
          enigma ~ 35 months ago
          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
          snak, I am unsure where you get your information that the milk changes taste? Also you cannot force a child to breastfeed ... they breastfeed because they gain nourishment and comfort from the experience.

          Anyway .. my daughter is 21 months and I am still breastfeeding - she has 12 teeth. I will breastfeed her until she self-weans.

          I breastfed my sons, well into 2½ years ....
          [ reply ]
          1.  
            graeme ~ 35 months ago
            0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
            some mother's can't breastfeed and there's a danger that they're left feeling guilty or inadequate by bottle feeding. It seems to me its possible to bring up perfectly healthy children either way and too much pressure on Mothers to take a particular approach (i.e. breast feeding) or maintain that approach for a set period of time is not helpful.
            [ reply ]
            1.  
              enigma ~ 35 months ago
              0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
              I agree totally with you graeme ... at the end of the day it is about what is best for your baby - to have a stressed mother who is in tears because she cannot get it right and a screaming hungry baby, or to have a serene bottle fed baby ...

              However to end, I think that it is not that certain mother's can't breastfeed as to rather a case of the support structures out there being so poor that it does not facilitate the breastfeeding experience.

              At the end of the day, whatever works for you - is what you make peace with ... regardless of what other's say.

              I am constantly treated with disgust when people find out that I am still breastfeeding my 21 month old ... tough on them ... it works for my daughter and I and that is all that matters!!
              [ reply ]
              1.  
                snak ~ 35 months ago
                0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                I can't remember my source for the info (probably New Scientist) but I have to agree that whatever works best for you and yours has to be the right way to go. It's alright for me (or anyone else) to spout 'facts' as determined by scientists, but what matters is how you interact with the 'real world'.
                [ reply ]
                1.  
                  Velvet ~ 35 months ago
                  0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                  My girlfriend breastfed until her son was 5... I was quite surprised when at social gatherings he would simply come to his mother pull up her top and suckle on her breast - I am not sure if he was still getting nurishment or if it was more a comfort zone for him... but it did cause quite the confilct at this one party.
                  [ reply ]
                  1.  
                    penumbra2000 ~ 33 months ago
                    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                    Wow... I just realised I'm reviving a long dead post. Sorry people. :)

                    Anyway, what I find really interesting is how charged people get about it. If there were a clear link between long-term breastfeeding and harm, I could see that there might be reason to argue; but that someone would freak at a party because someone else was living in a way that differed from theirs strikes me as self-righteous and intolerant, and emotionally damaging.
                    [ reply ]
                  2.  
                    milly ~ 35 months ago
                    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                    A while back I seen a programme on this on a UK channel - Ch 4. I was taken aback at the varying ages mothers were still feeding their kids at. One of the mothers was still feeding her 8 year old. Click on the link below.

                    I would have the opinion that once a child can hold / feed itself - that is the time to let go of the nipple! Its natural to see a young baby feeding from the breast, an eight year old just weird.

                    http://www.newsandstar.co...iewarticle.aspx?id=328277
                    [ reply ]
                    1.  
                      Mark ~ 35 months ago
                      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                      i remember that programe about the 8 year old still being breastfed..the mother must find it weird...and surely the kid finds it weird...imagine him telling his friends at school he is still on the tit.

                      on a related note..do any blokes find it awkward when they stumble across a woman breastfeeding..you dont know where to look...especially when they look at you and know your thinkin "move the head...move the head..damn kid"
                      [ reply ]
                      1.  
                        penumbra2000 ~ 33 months ago
                        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                        There's a short moment of discomfort, but I find it passes pretty quickly. I'd much rather see women feel comfortable about breastfeeding their kids than not have to feel a bit uncomfortable once in awhile.

                        As for thinking "move the head..." I would hope they would understand ;P
                        [ reply ]
                      2.  
                        JV ~ 35 months ago
                        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                        Has anyone seen the Little Britain parody of this? There is a guy still breastfeeding at age of 35
                        [ reply ]
                        1.  
                          Mark ~ 33 months ago
                          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                          lol..i have...i love that show
                          [ reply ]
                        2.  
                          georgie ~ 35 months ago
                          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                          In regards to what snak said about the taste of breast milk changing, I asked a colleague about this today (a former midwife) and she said that this does occur quite naturally for many mothers, though not always.

                          I think breast feeding does raise significant debate these days, which is the main reason I posted this article. The companies that produce infant formula would like us to believe that their product is just as healthy as mother's milk, and they go to great lengths to promote their products in American hospitals with free giveaways to new parents. Coupled with not enough breastfeeding support, as mentioned by enigma, I can understand why many new moms struggle and eventually turn to the bottle, either all the time or when needed. Breastfeeding can be hard work.

                          Mark and VS brought up the notion that people do feel conflicted about breastfeeding in public, especially of young children. It's interesting that some people feel uncomfortable with what seems to be a sexual undertone of this behavior. Attachment specialists might say that a child continuing to nurse at mother's breast would indicate a close, attentive and loving relationship where the child would experience mother as a secure, consistent base from which to explore the world. Some might also argue that breastfeeding longer may make it more difficult for children to wean as they get older, or as they are displaced by the arrival of a new sibling.
                          [ reply ]
                          1.  
                            georgie ~ 35 months ago
                            0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                            My midwife friend also said that breast milk can and does dry up, sometimes earlier than mothers anticipate. She knew one nursing mother who decided to clean and hoover the whole house, only to discover the next day that her milk had dried up after that manual labor. Does that seem right?
                            [ reply ]
                            1.  
                              talluleh28 ~ 35 months ago
                              0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                              Yes Georgie breastmilk can dry up if u are run down, stressed, or tire yourself out...it happenend to me with my first child.....very long story but she was 9 weeks premature....and had to stay in hospital for 6 weeks in order to grow to a certain weight and then they let her come home.....in the meantime i had to express milk every 3 hours for her to feed on. She had to be tube fed milk until she learnt to suck and then she fed at the breast when she was successful....in the meantime....i travelled to the hospital every day to sit with her from 9am to 8pm every night for 6 weeks....this took a toll on my body including my mind and my milk supply dropped and i couldn't keep with her needs...so i was giving tablets to increase my supply which worked but one of the side effects was total restlessness i couldn't even sleep!

                              Anyway the things u do to give your child the best possible start in life....cause i could of given in and just put her on formula but i didn't want to as breastmilk is THE BEST food for a child for the first 12 months or so of their life...

                              AND i really came here to see what Mark comments were cause I knew he would have written something that would be pervy LMAO and yep I wasn't disappointed!!!! LMAO
                              [ reply ]
                              1.  
                                talluleh28 ~ 35 months ago
                                0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                But i breastfed in public it didn't worry me at all....i made sure i covered up and no one saw anything to be offended.....my son though (he's the second child) used to like me sucking his fingers whilst he fed....NOW that used to get more of a reaction than him feeding in public...i don't know why he did it it was just a comfort thing for him and he still does it to this day he's 3 now and i have to suck his fingers for him to go to sleep..
                                [ reply ]
                                1.  
                                  natters1975 ~ 34 months ago
                                  0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                  My view is: if they're old enough to ask for it (or help themselves!) then they're too old to be breast-fed.
                                  [ reply ]
                                  1.  
                                    diddydi ~ 34 months ago
                                    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                    Better to breastfeed your baby to any age, than not at all. Breast is best. Bottle is foreign food.. If Mom and baby are happy, anything goes, but I think 5 years of age is pushing it a bit If I had my way, I,d ban the bottle....
                                    [ reply ]
                                    1.  
                                      xgames ~ 33 months ago
                                      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                      Eeeek! ..at age 5 ,,theres way to many teeth isnt there ?L.O.L.
                                      [ reply ]
                                      1.  
                                        xgames ~ 33 months ago
                                        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                        Eeeek! ..at age 5 ,,theres way to many teeth isnt there ?L.O.L.
                                        [ reply ]
                                        1.  
                                          Mark ~ 33 months ago
                                          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                          tally...im glad i didnt disappoint you with my totally out of character burst lol
                                          [ reply ]
                                          1.  
                                            talluleh28 ~ 32 months ago
                                            0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                            mark am I missing something???LOL
                                            [ reply ]
                                            1.  
                                              talluleh28 ~ 32 months ago
                                              0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                              i just realised what mark meant LOL im on my 4th guinness so carry on *LOL*
                                              [ reply ]
                                              1.  
                                                Mark ~ 32 months ago
                                                0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                ffs get with the program
                                                [ reply ]
                                              2.  
                                                armitage_shanks ~ 32 months ago
                                                0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                My mum asked me to stop because of the beard rash she was getting. hehe
                                                [ reply ]
                                                1.  
                                                  armitage_shanks ~ 32 months ago
                                                  0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                  ...last week
                                                  [ reply ]
                                                  1.  
                                                    Mark ~ 32 months ago
                                                    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                    bitty!
                                                    [ reply ]
                                                    1.  
                                                      smcphailbabylover2007 ~ 29 months ago
                                                      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                      As a very strong supporter of extended breastfeeding; I honestly don't believe that you all should be making a big deal out of this topic. Who cares if a nursing mother should decide to continue breastfeeding her child beyond an age as to what other people find totally unacceptable? To be honest., if I ever saw a mother breastfeeding her older child I would NOT say anything; besides, if I ever did, chances are that she'd more than likely would tell me where to head-in at! So therefore, if I were some of you I would just kindly and politely mind my own business and not be telling a nursing mother as to how long she should continue breastfeeding her child!!. I also don't believe that there is nothing sweeter than a nursing mother bonding with her child though breastfeeding!!. There are times when I'll visit other breastfeeding imternet sites and see photos of mothers breastfeeding their toddlers as well as their older children and I'll say to myself... How sweet is that?
                                                      THERE IS NOTHING ABSOLUTELY WRONG WITH EXTENDED BREASTFEEDING!! in fact, I give '' all'' nursing mothers my 100%support!!
                                                      [ reply ]
                                                      1.  
                                                        Mark ~ 29 months ago
                                                        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                        i gotta get them urls off you *nodz* can you see any nipple in the pics?
                                                        [ reply ]
                                                        1.  
                                                          22 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                                          This is my two cents...

                                                             
                                                          Hey you know AdGuy always gets the last word! ;)

                                                        Please Login to Add Your Comment   ..or..  

                                                        Replying to comment by