City or Country - Where Do You Really Want to Live?

Rate this:
By japaneseboats (Contact - View My Woyano)
Published Tue 24 Jul 2007, 975 Views, 19 Comments

Was half watching a BBC2 TV programme about 20th century inventions when the presenter, James May, said something like "the city is the greatest invention of the 20th century" - and that more people are moving there. This is curious as cities have existed for centuries - but I think he was getting at something else. Did any other Woyanos watch it?

To me it alludes to the debate on city versus country living. I was brought up, more or less, in the country but moved to the city - London - when I was 18 as a student, a hundred years ago. Never returned to live in the English countryside until approx eight years ago en route for rural France. For the first three or so years I missed London so much that I used to joke that my car was would take me straight back to London on the motorway if I ever took my eye off the route when driving on country roads. In fact I escaped as often as I could by train whenever I got the chance. Just to get a whiff of London taxi diesel fumes in my lungs. And an injection of liveliness and excitement and awareness. Besides I couldn't, and still can't, stand country drivers - especially those who don't know how to manage roundabouts and a million and one other aspects of driving a vehicle. Road rage is never far below the surface when I am driving in and around my country 'city' streets (in reality a market town of 40,000 inhabitants but called a city because of its cathedral). In fact I think my blood pressure have increased since I started living back here in the sticks. OK, it's not the same as living in a tiny village, but hey - not much different if you have arrived from London. I have to speak more slowly, and act more dense. Everything here is so slow and so smug. I don't mind slow, I love rural France. I do mind smug and obstructive. So why am I still here? Because I am still following plan A: en route to France. But in my dreams I live in Sydney, Australia. Another vibrant city. At the end of the world. Wow.

So where do other Woyanos live or want to live - city or country?


This Item
Category: Blogs, japaneseboats
Tags: city,country, lifestyle,
Contributor
japaneseboats
Share it
Link to this item:
Bookmark this item: RSS Feed

People who liked this item

    19 Comments

  1.  
    clemmati ~ 12 months ago
    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
    In a city. My early childhood, in the depths of West Wales, was idyllic. But I think a town is a better place to bring up children (a town of, say, 40,000 children!) and cities are better places to live. I like Cardiff but hanker after Montreal and Melbourne (I have relatives in Sydney but like the sound of Melbourne), and in the UK, Edinburgh.
    [ reply ]
    1.  
      jbravo ~ 12 months ago
      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
      The city I live in now, it turns out, is one of the best in the U.S. for raising a family. Since that's my number one priority right now, I guess I'm already in the perfect spot. Long term... haven't decided yet. But it has to have warm, sandy beaches. :-)
      Exactly where is not so important, because I intend to do a lot of traveling.
      [ reply ]
      1.  
        clemmati ~ 12 months ago
        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
        But I think a town is a better place to bring up children (a town of, say, 40,000 children!)

        Oops! goodness. I suspect a Freudian slip. Because actually I think a town of 40,000 people, like the one where my grammar school was, isn't in fact as good as a larger one. Cardiff, nearly 500,000, may be the ideal size, certainly people brought up here tend to like it and say they'd live and work here if their family weren't here!

        Hmmm warm sandy beaches, Sydney, I think, for you...
        [ reply ]
      2.  
        Loves Bloc Party ~ 12 months ago
        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
        i want to live near the beach, eat fresh fruit, swim, and enjoy the beautiful sunsets

        *S* but maybe far enough away i dont get hit too hard by a hurricane
        [ reply ]
        1.  
          jbravo ~ 12 months ago
          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
          Wow -- there's actually something we agree on. Will wonders never cease? :-)
          The good thing about hurricanes is at least you get plenty of advanced warning.
          [ reply ]
        2.  
          randomglenn ~ 12 months ago
          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
          I want to live in the city again . Living in sydney was an all round good experience for me.
          [ reply ]
          1.  
            earsz ~ 12 months ago
            0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
            City, definitely. I hated growing up (teens) in rural Arkansas. There wasn't even a town, though there was a community because of school. I'll be circumspect in comment since the folk I grew up with mostly still live there, but I don't go back, nor do I ever want its equivalent. In dating, a partner's expressed desire to move to a small town somewhere was a deal-breaking development that abruptly ended any budding relationship. But, all things for all people: I have a brother who chose the exact opposite and rejects wealthy women who want him to leave his lakeside to move into San Francisco or the like. And another brother who tries to have it both ways _ living in the (suburban) city but on a small acreage with chickens, a horse and a barn, for instance. Ironically, though, still living in the city, now I skip just about all its amenities and merely stay home. *siiigh*
            [ reply ]
            1.  
              prettyfly ~ 12 months ago
              0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
              I grew up in quite a large town 75,000 people and couldn't wait to leave to go to uni in a city. Once I graduated I returned home but lived in the city, however after my marriage went to the dogs I've moved back to my hometown and have settled remarkably well - although I do still work in the city (longer commute) As for living in a completely rural area - its a 'no can do' for me. I love renting a cottage for a weekend or weeks gettaway in the country - but its always great to get back to 'civilisation'.
              [ reply ]
              1.  
                wyldcat ~ 12 months ago
                0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                Wow. I feel like odd man out, here LOL I can't take the city at all. People are rude, parking is expensive or not existant, society's ultimate downfalls are shoved into your face on a daily basis. No....nuh uh....not for me.

                I love sitting on my front porch, listening to the gentle splash of the waterfall into our fish pond. I love not having to lock the door to my house. I love leaving the keys hanging in my car ignition overnight, knowing that all my neighbors do the exact same thing and no one's going to touch it. I love that I only have to drive 7 minutes to buy groceries, but I have almost a full acre of land and a creek in my backyard for my boys to throw rocks into, catch fish, or trap a bullfrog. I love that I know which tree is in bloom just by sniffing the air, or walking behind my neighbor's house and picking a full basket of wild raspberries to throw on my cereal in the morning. We're a population of only 12,000 and I wouldn't want to live anywhere else.

                We have run into 1 problem, though. My oldest son has Nystagmus, which is an eye condition that has made him blind in one eye and extremely near sighted in his good eye. He'll never be able to drive a car. The doctors have told us that he'll need to move to a city as an adult in order to be able to take advantage of things like public transportation and being able to walk to places for food or supplies.

                So, depending on when he wants to go out on his own or gets married or whatever the future holds, I may have to become a city girl....whether it's to make his life easier, or just to visit. However, I will always be a country girl at heart.
                [ reply ]
                1.  
                  jbravo ~ 12 months ago
                  1 vote thumbs up thumbs down
                  I'm very sorry to hear about your son's condition. I wish your family the best going forward.

                  I'd be perfectly happy living in a small town -- as long as I had high-speed internet, and the means to get out and travel often. :-)
                  [ reply ]
                  1.  
                    japaneseboats ~ 12 months ago
                    1 vote thumbs up thumbs down
                    I'm also sorry to hear abt yr son's condition and send you all best wishes for his, and your future together. Your current location sounds wonderful - and I would work hard at looking for solutions to keep it if I could. But the hard truth is that children make their own choices and it may be that yr son might prefer city life. How wonderful if he could have both - loving and supportive mum in the country and a practical, fulfilling life in the city? My kids are all grown up and continue to surprise me, despite difficulties that they have sometimes had to overcome :)
                    [ reply ]
                  2.  
                    vadagh ~ 12 months ago
                    0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                    definitely not the city, I've lived in NY, San Fran, Hull, Nottingham and London. All possess one thing I can't stand too many of.......people. nutters, whack-jobs, robbers, drunken yobs and general bad vibes and in San Frans case deviants.
                    I'm quite content where I am a small town , where no-one knows me and leaves me alone. But close enough to the city to be able to get there within half an hour.
                    [ reply ]
                    1.  
                      japaneseboats ~ 12 months ago
                      0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                      Thanks for all yr comments - cities seem to win - but maybe I was a bit hard on the countryside as I too had an idyllic childhood spent mostly in the country. As an adult, I just miss the vibrancy of city life. I am lucky to have had the experience of many cities around the world, have lived in a few, and I just love them all. I forgot to mention Paris - my real true love - discovered shortly after London. The best cities have inner 'villages' formed from the various communities that settled particular areas in the past. Lately for me, Sydney is just perfect. An exciting but laid back city, with interesting 'villages' and great beaches. Would it be a great place to bring up children? Due to my father's job, I lived close to another Australian city for a while in my youth, and loved it. Funnily, it was a shock to me to discover that my children, were all Londoners. How did that happen? :)
                      [ reply ]
                      1.  
                        Mark ~ 12 months ago
                        0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                        i grew up in dublin (a very small city compared to alot of cities most of you would be living in)...and i think it has all the best clubs...the best women...my best friends live there...2 years ago i moved to the countryside...and even though i feel the city has all that...i just love the countryside..the craic in the pubs is brilliant...always a laugh...often a lock in...on days off if i want to drive anywhere...i can drive for hours without even having to stop at traffic lights let alone in traffic...green fields and amazing scenary right at my front door...i dont think i could ever live in a city again
                        [ reply ]
                        1.  
                          japaneseboats ~ 12 months ago
                          0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                          For goodness sake Mark - you are talking about Ireland - kingdom of the gods. Of course it is the best place in the world! ( Except if we all moved there:D)
                          [ reply ]
                          1.  
                            Mark ~ 12 months ago
                            0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                            lol..i forgot myself...how dare me
                            [ reply ]
                            1.  
                              Mark ~ 12 months ago
                              0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                              so good i posted it twice but took one of them back...
                              [ reply ]
                          2.  
                            snak ~ 12 months ago
                            0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                            The country for me every time. I grew up on the outskirts of a city but spent my teenage years & early 20's by the sea. Moved to the city when I got married. Hated it. Every time you look out of the window you see - more windows. And bricks. And ugly people, too much in a rush to have the time to be nice.

                            I now live in the country, and would not move back into the filthy, smelly, ar*seh*le that is a city. Interestingly, the poisoning from car exhaust fumes in a city lowers the intelligence in children by a significant percent.

                            Said God to St. Peter: The Earth needs an enema. Where do I stick the pipe?
                            St Peter to God: Just pick a city, lord. Just pick a city.
                            [ reply ]
                            1.  
                              Tequila Rose ~ 12 months ago
                              0 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                              I like city life for now- it caters to my personality- but I grew up small town- so i do like the quiet life as well- probably if I decide to settle down for a family- i'll move back to the midwest- or somewhere farther away from the BIG cities- there are many towns in the midwest that fit a little bit in between- big city/small town-

                              denver, KC, St. Louis somewhat.. etc.. Cost of living is still affordable, traffic isn't so bad- but you can still enjoy sports teams, theme parks, operas, concerts, etc.
                              [ reply ]
                              1.  
                                22 votes thumbs up thumbs down
                                This is my two cents...

                                   
                                Hey you know AdGuy always gets the last word! ;)

                              Please Login to Add Your Comment   ..or..  

                              Replying to comment by